1932

New Bedford Whalers

1L

3-3

Stix, Baer and Fuller

(New Bedford, MA)

2L

5-2

(St. Louis, MO)

1931

Fall River Marksmen

1L

6-2

Bricklayers F.C.

(Fall River, MA)

2L

2-0

(Chicago, IL)

1930

Fall River Marksmen

1L

7-2

Bruell Insurance

(Fall River, MA)

2L

2-1

(Cleveland, OH)

1929

Hakoah All Stars

1L

2-0

Madison Kennels

(New York, NY)

2L

3-0

(St. Louis, MO)

1928

New York Nationals

2-2 (aet)

Bricklayers F.C.

 (New York, NY)

R

3-0

(Chicago, IL)

1927

Fall River Marksmen

7-0

Holley Carburetor

(Fall River, MA)

(Detroit, MI)

1926

Bethlehem Steel

7-2

Ben Miller A.C.

 (Bethlehem, PA)

(St. Louis, MO)

1925

Shawsheen Indians

3-0

Canadian Club

(Andover, MA)

(Chicago, IL)

1924

Fall River Marksmen

4-2

Vesper Buick

(Fall River, MA)

(St. Louis, MO)

1923

Paterson Silk Sox

2-2

Scullin Steel

(Paterson, NJ)

(aet)

(St. Louis, MO)

Scullin unable to play replay due to injuries and players fullfilling baseball contracts

1922

Scullin Steel

3-2

Todd Shipyards

(St. Louis, MO)

(Brooklyn, NY)

1921

Robbins Dry Dock

4-2

Scullin Steel

(Brooklyn, NY)

(St. Louis, MO)

1920

Ben Miller A.C.

2-1

Fore River F.C.

(St. Louis, MO)

(Quincy, MA)

1919

Bethlehem Steel

2-0

Paterson F.C.

 (Bethlehem, PA)

(Paterson, NJ)

1918

Bethlehem Steel

2-2

Fall River Rovers

 (Bethlehem, PA)

R

3-0

(Fall River, MA)

1917

Fall River Rovers

1-0

Bethlehem Steel

(Fall River, MA)

 (Bethlehem, PA)

1916

Bethlehem Steel

1-0

Fall River Rovers

(Bethlehem, PA) 

(Fall River, MA)

1915

Bethlehem Steel

3-1

Brooklyn Celtic

 (Bethlehem, PA)

 (Brooklyn, NY)

1914

Brooklyn Field Club

2-1

Brooklyn Celtic

 (Brooklyn, NY)

(Brooklyn, NY)

asdet - after sudden death extra time  / PK - Penalty Kicks / R - Replay

1L - 1st Leg / 2L - 2nd Leg / 3L - 3rd leg