1945	Brookhattan F.C.	1L	4-1	Cleveland Americans
	(New York, NY)	2L	2-1	(Cleveland, OH)
1944	Brooklyn Hispano		4-0	Morgan-Strasser
	(Brooklyn, NY)			(Pittsburgh, PA)
1943	Brooklyn Hispano		2-2 (aet)	Morgan-Strasser
	(Brooklyn, NY)	R	3-2	(Pittsburgh, PA)
1942	Gallatin S.C.	1L	2-1	Pawtucket F.C.
	(Pittsburgh, PA)	2L	4-2	(Pawtucket, RI)
1941	Pawtucket Rangers	1L	4-2	Chrysler S.C.
	(Pawtucket, RI)	2L	4-3 (aet)	(Detroit, MI)
1940	Baltimore S.C.	1L	0-0	Sparta A & BA
	(Baltimore, MD)	2L	2-2 (aet)	(Chicago, IL)
	Baltimore and Sparta declared Co-Champions
1939	St. Mary’s Celtic	1L	1-0	Manhattan Beer
	(Brooklyn, NY)	2L	4-1	(Chicago, IL)
1938	Sparta A & BA	1L	4-0	St. Mary’s Celtic
	(Chicago, IL)	2L	4-2	(Brooklyn, NY)
1937	New York American	1L	0-2	Shamrocks
	(New York, NY)	2L	4-1	(St. Louis, MO)
1936	German-Americans	1L	2-2	Shamrocks
	(Philadelphia, PA)	2L	3-1	(St. Louis, MO)
1935	Central Breweries	1L	5-1	Pawtucket Rangers
	(St. Louis, MO)	2L	1-1 (aet)	(Pawtucket, RI)
		3L	1-3
1934	Stix, Baer and Fuller	1L	4-2 (aet)	Pawtucket Rangers
	(St. Louis, MO)	2L	2-3	(Pawtucket, RI)
		3L	5-0
1933	Stix, Baer and Fuller	1L	1-0	New York Americans
	(St. Louis, MO)	2L	2-1	(New York, NY)
asdet - after sudden death extra time  / PK - Penalty Kicks / R - Replays
1L - 1st Leg / 2L - 2nd Leg / 3L - 3rd leg